This is a stock-specific “hold vs exit” query; below is an objective assessment based on latest publicly available data.

1. Current snapshot – Shivam Autotech Ltd (SHIVAMAUTO)

- CMP: ~₹23–25 (late Dec 2025), down ~40% over 1 year; trading near 52‑week low of ~₹24.8 vs high ~₹50.1. (stockanalysis.com)

- Market cap: ~₹330–350 crore; small-cap, high volatility (beta >2 on longer look-back). (stockanalysis.com)

- FY25 (year ended Mar 2025): Revenue ~₹454 crore, net loss ~₹48 crore (loss also in FY24 ~₹50 crore). (business-standard.com)

- Last 4 quarters: Continuous net losses; Sep 2025 loss ~₹12.4 crore, Jun 2025 loss ~₹17.7 crore, pressure on sales and margins. (business-standard.com)

- Financial quality:

- Negative ROE for 3 consecutive years.

- Company has posted losses for 4 consecutive quarters.

- Interest cost heavy (interest ~13% of operating revenue in FY25). (economictimes.indiatimes.com)

- Balance sheet: Very high liabilities vs market cap; external analysis flags meaningful debt risk and weak coverage ratios. (tipranks.com)

2. What this broadly implies

- Fundamentals:

- Persistent losses, negative ROE, and high finance costs indicate the core business is not yet generating sustainable returns to equity.

- No dividend; earnings visibility is weak until a clear turnaround (profitability + deleveraging) is demonstrated.

- Balance‑sheet risk:

- High leverage and liabilities bigger than market cap mean any downturn or execution miss can quickly translate into dilution risk (equity raising at low prices) or other forms of financial stress. (simplywall.st)

- Valuation & price action:

- P/E is not meaningful (loss-making); P/B and EV/EBITDA are not clearly “bargain” territory considering consistent losses and leverage. (tipranks.com)

- Price trending down near 52‑week lows suggests sentiment and market positioning are weak.

3. Example framework: when “hold” vs “exit” can be considered (not a recommendation)

This is general information, not personalised advice:

- Example where investors often choose to reduce/exit

- Long‑term, conservative focus on profitable, low‑debt businesses.

- Stock forms a large % of portfolio (concentration risk).

- No clear evidence yet of turnaround in quarterly numbers (still loss‑making, high interest cost).

- In such cases, many investors prefer to exit on any bounce/strength and redeploy into financially stronger names in the auto‑ancillary space.

- Example where some might continue to hold with strict risk control

- Very small allocation (speculative portion of portfolio).

- High risk tolerance and willingness to see volatility/drawdowns.

- Clear personal thesis on:

- capacity utilisation improving,

- OEM orders ramping up, and

- future reduction in debt/interest burden.

- In this scenario, investors typically keep a pre‑defined stop‑loss around/below recent lows and a time limit (e.g., review around the next 1–2 result seasons) rather than holding indefinitely.

4. Practical next steps for you

As a SEBI‑regulated research environment, we cannot give a direct “buy/hold/sell” call here tailored to you. A prudent way to decide:

1. Compare CMP vs your buy price (what % gain/loss).

2. Check portfolio weight of Shivam Autotech; trim if exposure is high relative to your risk capacity.

3. Track the next couple of quarterly results (next scheduled earnings around Feb 2026) specifically for:

- return to profit,

- reduction in debt or interest cost,

- sustained revenue growth. (stockanalysis.com)

If losses persist and leverage remains elevated, fundamentally the stock tends to fit a “high‑risk, avoid/only speculative” bucket for many investors rather than a core long‑term hold.

If you have any further queries, please connect with us on 022-6290-10141 (Timings : 09.00 AM to 05.00 PM) or you can email us on info@cniinfoxchange.com